Movie Review: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1

In retrospect, I’m not sure if my review of Deathly Hallows: Part 2 can be considered complete without the companion review for Part 1, much like how I feel about the movies themselves.  I would like to revise this review to include more plot detail, but considering this is the seventh film in an eight-part series, this would be difficult for me to do without including spoilers.


This is an absolutely phenomenal film.   It is my favorite film in the franchise and is one of my favorite films of 2010, a powerful year for movies overall.  (In retrospect, after having seen Deathly Hallows: Part 2, it’s very difficult for me to decide which of those two movies is my favorite of the franchise.  They both have very powerful and very distinct strengths, as discussed in the second film’s review.)

“Half-Blood Prince” was a letdown only in the sense that it wasn’t as absolutely mind-blowing for me as “Order of the Phoenix” was, instead settling for being merely “quite decent.”  I don’t know why it didn’t thrill me as much as the movie before or after it.  Maybe because I thought the book was only decent and liked books 5 and 7 better?

Deathly Hallows, on the other hand, starts out strong and with only the faintest of pacing missteps and slowdowns, powers through two and a half hours’ worth of an impeccable balance between intense action and engrossing exposition.

The acting is superb.  Main leads Daniel Radcliffe (Harry Potter), Rupert Grint (Ron Weasley), and Emma Watson (Hermione Granger) head up an incredible cast and are amazingly talented in their own right.  Watson is absolutely heartbreaking, since she seems to be the only one of the three main characters who doesn’t lose their mind at some point, with an explanation that is handled just as logically and understandably as it was in the book.  One of her scenes toward the end of the film is almost too convincing, making the story’s brutal tone that much more personal and horrifying.

The movie is probably not “accessible” for people who haven’t read all the books and perhaps watched all the films (you’re probably not going to understand what Horcruxes are and why they are important just from watching the movie), but for those familiar with the source material, even if they haven’t actually read it in a while, they’ll find a shining example of how a book-to-movie adaptation should be made.

The film’s structure brought few surprises but was solid enough not to really need them.  (I walked in the theatre having a good idea of what event the film would end on.  I was correct to within about a minute of screen time.)  Series veterans will likely receive just what they expect to get from this extended “setup sequence” as the film series prepares for its final installment.  One notable exception is an engrossing story-within-a-story animated sequence which fits perfectly within the comparatively dark tone of this film.

Some of the action-scene camera work is a bit difficult to follow, but the wand fights feel as intense and breathless as any gunfight in a modern action movie.  The computer-generated creatures are as breathtaking to look at as they ever were, but the story and script stand proudly on their own, turning a simple quest to destroy various magical objects into a poignant examination of character and personal relationships.  The film masterfully shifts back and forth between depression and happiness, with the best examples including one particular slow-dance sequence that would feel random if it weren’t executed so completely and utterly naturally.

I really can’t say enough about this film.  Small pacing lags and accessibility are probably my only real complaints about the film, but the former is a minor complaint, and the latter can’t be helped in a movie that serves as half of an adaptation of the final installment in a long-running book series.  I can’t wait to see this movie again.


6 thoughts on “Movie Review: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1

    • Thank you very much! I truly appreciate your thoughts and your compliments. If you don’t mind my asking, what were your thoughts on preferring Part 2 over Part 1? (Have a nice weekend, God bless! I need to decide what and when I’m going to post next, since I have no money to go see any new movies right now. Maybe I should stop by the library and check something out.)

      • Part 2 was more fast paced. Part 1 was rather slow. And yet when reading the book, i didnt feel it was slow. Thats why i felt part 2 is better. (Have you read hunger games? if you have not, you should read the trilogy. Its awesome!)

        • Fair enough. I can definitely see that, though I thought Deathly Hallows Part 1 was, for the most part, paced well enough on its own. I’ve heard of The Hunger Games books but haven’t read them, thanks; what are they about?)

        • I know this is an old comment (which I still appreciate ^_^), but I eventually did get around to reading The Hunger Games novels. I thought the second was pretty good, and the third was a fairly standard war story (rather gory for a teen/young-adult book, maybe?), but the first is probably the best piece of teen/YA literature I have ever read. I finished nearly all of it in a single sitting. The pacing was extraordinary, and the action was tragic yet tense.

          I also read Battle Royale, which is a much more adult (mostly graphic violence and language) version of a similar plot, but I loved the wide variety of character perspectives (not just one focal person like Katniss in THG). More to the point, pretty much all those characters were developed amazingly well. I absolutely adored that book.

    • In retrospect, I really should thank you more for your commenting on Part 1 of my review. I did write these in chronological order (I watched Deathly Hallows Part 1 back in … January? as part of a $3 second run), and I’m a lot more proud of my Part 2 review, so I’m really thankful that you like the first one, too. Take care!

Share your thoughts here.

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s